All lessonsBeliefs & Identity

The Widest Range Wins: Why Flexibility Beats Force in Every Founder System

In 2002 I won a district speaking championship as the last of thirteen speakers, with no notes and no plan, because every rival had a method and I had a repertoire. Here is the cybernetic law underneath that win, and the identity sentence that quietly narrows a founder's range.

2026-09-17 3,711 words 19 min read

Thirteen Speakers, One Slot, and No Plan at All

In 2002 I walked into a ballroom at Raffles City late, holding no notes and no memory that I had entered a contest at all.

The contest chair had phoned me days earlier to ask if I was ready for the Evaluation Speech Contest. I had won the division level and then filed the whole thing away, because I was in the middle of starting a company. I did not know the venue. I wrapped up early, walked down from my office, and arrived to find twelve other competitors already gathered.

We drew lots. Thirteen entries, and I pulled number thirteen. The last speaker.

They took our notes away after a limited preparation period and put us in a holding area. I spent that hour pacing, and pacing gave me something worth more than preparation. It let me read the field.

Every competitor in that holding area had a method. One group was building acronyms, the way the previous year's runner up had. Another had a memorised structure they trusted. Another was rehearsing a dramatic opening. Each of them had taken a single designed move and sharpened it to a fine edge. Twelve well-prepared people, twelve shapes.

I had spent years losing to exactly that. Two disqualifications in 1998 for running out of time. First runner up at club, area, and division through 1999 and 2000. A district final in Hong Kong where I stood in front of five hundred people and remember only the spotlights and stepping down, beaten by a sixty-year-old grandmother talking about her grandchildren while I was twenty-six. Seven years of working hard and coming second.

Sometime in that holding area I stopped trying to win the preparation competition, because twelve people were going to beat me at it. I made a different decision. I would memorise everything, deliver one point instead of the customary three or five, and walk up with no notes at all.

When they finally called my name, the Toastmaster of the day held out the envelope of notes and asked whether I wanted it. I pushed it aside in full view of the judges and the audience and said no thank you.

The speaker under evaluation had delivered a talk about emotion moments earlier, in a flat, level, uncharged voice. I named that incongruence for the room. Then I demonstrated the alternative in my own delivery. I watched heads move among the judges. I had memorised my timing the same way I had memorised the content, and the moment the red light came on, I landed on my final two words.

They announced the runner up. They announced second place. Then the champion of the District 51 Evaluation Speech Contest 2002 went to me.

The lesson I carried out of that room had nothing to do with speaking. Every other competitor brought one designed move. I brought a repertoire and picked the move the room needed. That is the whole game, and it applies to a sales call, a price negotiation, a hiring decision, and a Tuesday morning crisis with identical force.

The Law That Explains Why Force Loses

There is a formal version of what happened in that ballroom, and it was published forty-six years before the contest.

In 1956, W. Ross Ashby set out the law of requisite variety in An Introduction to Cybernetics. Stated in his own compressed form, only variety can destroy variety. The longer reading is the one that matters for a founder. A regulator can absorb only those disturbances it has the internal variety to match, and when the disturbance exceeds that variety, control collapses regardless of how much force the regulator applies.

Strip the mathematics and you get a working rule for business. The participant with more available responses controls the encounter. The participant with fewer responses has to force, because forcing is the only move left when the range runs out.

Stafford Beer carried the principle into management in Brain of the Firm in 1972, arguing that a manager's capacity to regulate a complex operation depends on the variety the manager can bring to it. Donella Meadows made the same point in plain language in Thinking in Systems in 2008. A system's behaviour is set by its structure, and a regulator that is simpler than the disturbance it faces will be overwhelmed by it.

The NLP tradition took this principle and made it a presupposition. Robert Dilts and Judith DeLozier set it out in the Encyclopedia of Systemic NLP in 2000: the person with the most flexibility of behaviour will control the system. It arrived in the field as a modelling observation rather than a derived theorem, and I label it that way here, because the honesty matters. The cybernetic principle is proven inside control theory. Its application to human rooms is a metaphor of real practical value, and I will come back to that distinction later.

Now look at what escalation costs. Barry Staw described escalation of commitment in the Academy of Management Review in 1981. People and organisations commit further resources to a failing course of action to justify what they have already spent. Every founder who has thrown a second marketing budget at a channel that did not work has met this firsthand.

Here is the part that connects the two ideas. Escalation is what rigidity looks like on a spreadsheet. When your only move is a discount, a bigger push, or one more hire, the escalation is not a strategy failure. It is a range failure wearing a strategy costume.

Why Range Narrows Through Success

You would expect a narrow repertoire to come from failure. In my experience with founders it comes from the opposite direction, and that is why almost nobody audits it.

The sequence runs in four movements and I have watched it in marketing-led firms, operations-led firms, and founder-led firms with equal reliability.

First, an outlier strength produces early success. One way of working lifts the business out of the danger zone. The founder is a brilliant closer, or a brilliant builder, or a brilliant storyteller, and the market rewards that specific move.

Second, reinforcement takes over. The move worked, so it becomes the move. Every problem gets routed through the strength, because the strength is the thing with evidence behind it. A marketer reads every problem as a funnel problem. An operator reads every problem as a process problem. A visionary reads every problem as an idea problem.

Third, the neglected responses quietly atrophy. Abilities that were never practised the way the primary one was practised fall out of reach. For every area of unusual competence, a corresponding area of unusual incompetence develops on the same schedule.

Fourth, scale arrives and the disturbance outgrows the regulator. The channel that carried you to one million stops working at five. The team that thrived on your presence starts fragmenting when you are spread across three countries. The single move that built the business becomes the constraint that caps it, and the founder's instinct is to run the move harder.

Failure sends people looking for alternatives. Success sends them back to the same door. That is the trap, and it explains why the most capable founders are often the ones with the narrowest range. Their ability to make one move work exceptionally well delays the moment they discover they need another one.

The uncomfortable truth sits here. Your greatest strength is not the thing you built the business on. It is the thing that will define your ceiling, and it will do it while feeling virtuous the entire way.

The Sentence That Narrows the Range

Range is not lost at the level of skill. It is lost at the level of identity, which is why training programmes that add tactics rarely change how a founder behaves under pressure.

I met this in my own history before I had any business to run. In 1988, at thirteen, I scraped into the express stream by a few points and was, by every measure the school used, a poor student. Then my parents sent me to a preview of an accelerated learning course. I spent the June holidays learning a methodology for studying. In July, at the next monthly test, I came first in my class, with an average more than twenty per cent higher than before. A classmate asked whether I had cheated.

I had not cheated the test. I had swapped the method I was failing with for one I had never run. That swap required me to stop protecting the identity of the student I thought I was, and the identity was the expensive part. The method was available to anyone in the room.

Psychology has a name for the fragility that protects a narrow identity. Patricia Linville published work in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology in 1987 showing that self-complexity, meaning the number of distinct and independent ways a person understands themselves, buffers against stress and illness. A self built around one aspect has further to fall when that aspect is threatened. Applied to a founder, a single-aspect identity turns every strategic challenge into an existential one, because any alternative to the one move reads as a threat to who you are.

Carol Dweck's work on fixed and growth mindsets, gathered in Mindset in 2006, covers the same ground from the motivational side. A fixed view of ability makes a new method a verdict on your talent. A growth view makes it an experiment.

Listen for the sentences. I am a closer. I am the operator. I am the creative. I am not a numbers person. Each of those sentences buys internal coherence and charges rent in range. The founder who is a closer cannot run a value conversation that ends without a close, because a no-contact outcome would put the identity on trial.

Here is what that looks like in a live room. The founder who has built twenty years of reputation on being the smartest person at the table struggles when the right move is to say nothing and let the client talk. Silence is available to everyone. It is unavailable to a man whose identity requires the room to hear him think.

What Range Is Not

Three mistranslations of this idea cause real damage, and I want them named before the protocol.

Range is not inconsistency. The founder whose position shifts with every conversation has not widened the repertoire, because a position that moves under pressure is not a position. Ashby's regulator absorbs disturbance through internal variety that the regulator itself selects. Somebody with no stable standard has no regulator at all, and that produces drift rather than control.

Range is not novelty for its own sake. Adding untested moves to feel adaptable is another way of avoiding the discipline of choosing. The repertoire exists to be selected from, not displayed. In the 2002 contest I had more moves available than my rivals and I used two of them deliberately.

Range is not a substitute for strategy. A founder needs a settled direction and a wide set of routes to it. Confusing the two produces the frantic company that pivots quarterly and calls it agility.

Elaine Pulakos and her colleagues gave the concept structure in the Journal of Applied Psychology in 2000, publishing a taxonomy of adaptive performance built from supervisor ratings across many jobs. Adaptability there is not a general trait. It resolves into distinct capacities, including handling emergencies and crisis situations, solving problems creatively, handling uncertain and unpredictable work situations, learning new tasks and technologies, and demonstrating interpersonal adaptability. That breakdown matters for a founder, because it tells you the repertoire is trainable in parts. Most founders discover they hold one or two of those capacities at a high level and have never tested the others.

Roger Fisher and William Ury made the negotiation case in Getting to Yes in 1981. Their instruction to negotiate on interests rather than positions, and to generate several options before choosing, is a range argument built for a table with two parties and one outcome. The party with four possible agreements to propose cannot be cornered by a refusal, because a refusal closes one route and the others remain open.

The Honest Limits of What I Can Claim

Two disclosures, in the order they matter.

First, the law of requisite variety is a proven result inside control theory, where the variety of a regulator and the variety of its disturbances can both be specified precisely. A human organisation is not a closed control system and its variety cannot be measured the way an engineer measures it. The transfer of the law into leadership language is a metaphor that earns its keep through usefulness, and the research support comes from neighbouring literatures rather than from Ashby's theorem itself. Where I use the word law, I mean the cybernetic result. Where I apply it to your business, I am reasoning by analogy, and I have labelled it as such.

Second, the NLP presupposition about flexibility arrived through a modelling tradition rather than through experiment. The traditions of Bandler and Grinder produced a body of practitioner craft from the 1970s onward, and its presuppositions function as working heuristics. Treat that sentence as a lens that sharpens observation, not as a finding.

What I can defend is narrower and more useful. The self-complexity research, the adaptability taxonomy, and the escalation-of-commitment literature all point the same way. Narrower repertoires correlate with poorer outcomes under stress and uncertainty, and sustained rigidity in the face of contradicting evidence produces escalating cost. That is a modest claim, and it is the one I am making.