The Shooter Who Rehearsed in His Sleep
In 2001 the Singapore Armed Forces shooting contingent had dropped from second to fourth place in the regional competition. I was brought in, unpaid, working on pure fascination. My brief sounds simple typed out: model the top performers and find out what they were doing that nobody could articulate. It turned out to be one of the hardest questions I have ever chased, because the answer lived in a place none of them could reach with words.
I interviewed eight elite shooters. I set up video recorders to capture eye movements, body language, accessing cues, the small physical tells that run underneath conscious attention. Then I watched the footage back until the patterns stopped being noise. The top performer rehearsed in his sleep. His body physically twitched while he ran his mental range: chamber the round, sight alignment, breath control, trigger squeeze. He was not aware of it. His wife was the one who told me.
Another shooter screamed before his rundowns. Not a battle cry. A deliberate emotional amplification. He was spiking his adrenaline to match competition conditions so his body would not be surprised by pressure on the day. A third stood in rainstorms and rehearsed the entire sequence under adverse conditions his conscious self had never prepared for. None of them could explain what they were doing. When I asked directly, they gave me the same three empty sentences I have heard from high performers in every field since: I focus. I practise a lot. I stay calm.
Here is the detail that changed how I think about expertise. The shooter who rehearsed in his sleep was running the most precise training of the group, and he could not tell me a single thing about it. His expertise had moved below his awareness, and the only place it still showed up was in his body, in the middle of the night, while he slept. The data about his peak performance was sitting inside him, invisible to his own conscious report, visible only to someone willing to treat his internal experience as real evidence.
That is the entire subject of this article, and it is the line I have watched divide people for three decades. Most people will not treat that twitching body as data. They will ask for a study, a certificate, a controlled trial before they credit a single thing the body is broadcasting. The ones who benefit from the discipline I teach make a different decision first. They treat their own internal experience as evidence worth attending to. Everything else follows from that choice.
What It Means to Treat Internal Experience as Data
Let me be precise about the phrase, because it is the hinge of this whole conversation. Treating internal experience as data means deciding that what you feel, picture, hear inside your own head, and notice in your own body counts as information about how you actually operate, information that is worth recording, weighing, and acting on, the same way you treat a spreadsheet, a customer interview, or a revenue number.
The clearest demonstration I have ever seen is that sleeping shooter. His twitching was not meaningless spasm. It was rehearsal, and it was precise. If I had dismissed it as the body doing something odd at night, I would have thrown away the single most important finding of the entire modelling project: that the best performer in the country was training eight hours a day in his sleep without knowing it. The data was real. It was internal. And it was the difference between first place and the field.
This is not mysticism. It is the practical claim that sits underneath the entire discipline. When I modelled that marksman, I was not asking him to believe anything about energy or metaphysics. I was treating his subjective experience, his mental imagery, his internal dialogue, his felt sense of the shot, as legitimate phenomena with their own structure, structure that could be observed, mapped, and taught to other men. The discipline of modelling excellence is built on exactly that wager: internal experience has structure, that structure is readable, and reading it changes outcomes.
Here is where I want to name the honest tension, because it matters. There are two legitimate ways to decide what counts as evidence, and they produce opposite answers about this work. The first says evidence is whatever can be observed from the outside and repeated by anyone, ideally in a controlled setting. Under that standard, an internal twitch in a sleeping man is anecdote until someone proves it generalizes. The second says evidence includes your own systematic experience of what works in your own life and the lives of people you watch closely. Under that standard, a pattern you have seen hold across decades of real rooms is evidence even if no laboratory has yet signed off on it. The people who get value from this work tend to run the second operating system. The people who dismiss it tend to run only the first.
The Divide Is Not About Technique, It Is About Epistemology
This exact divide surfaced in a large online discussion in May 2025, where practitioners and skeptics went back and forth over whether the discipline actually works. The thread was long, heated, and, from where I sit, almost entirely beside the point, because the two sides were not arguing about the same thing. Practitioners described internal experiences they could reproduce and outcomes they had watched change. Skeptics demanded external, repeatable proof before they would credit any of it. Both were being internally consistent. They were running different rules for what counts as knowledge.
The philosopher's word for this is epistemology, the study of what counts as evidence and how we know what we know. I do not use it often outside a training room, but here it earns its place, because it names the real conflict. This is not a fight between people who practise and people who do not. It is a structural difference in where each side looks for truth. One side looks inward at experience. The other looks outward at measurement. Neither position is crazy. What is crazy is expecting one to convince the other, because they are not even speaking the same language of proof.
Now bring that into a founder context, because this is where it stops being academic. A founder who refuses to treat internal experience as data will dismiss their own signal: the unease before a hire, the dread that has been building for months about a strategy, the exhaustion that says the operating model is breaking before the numbers admit it. They will wait for the spreadsheet to confirm what their body has been telling them for a quarter. When the spreadsheet finally confirms it, the cost has already been paid. The leader who treats internal experience as data reads the unease early, investigates it with the same rigour they would give a bad number, and often corrects course before the damage compounds.
That is the practical payoff, and it has nothing to do with believing anything you feel is true. It is about giving internal experience a seat at the table of your decision making, subjecting it to the same scrutiny you give external evidence, and refusing to let one type of evidence run the room alone.
The Mechanism in Plain English
Underneath all of this sits a mechanism worth making explicit, because once you see it, the whole approach stops feeling abstract. The human mind runs most of its expertise below the level of conscious report. When you rehearse a skill enough times, the sequence stops needing your attention and starts running automatically. The marksman who had trained for years did not think through sight alignment and trigger squeeze in the moment. His nervous system ran the whole sequence on its own, faster and more consistently than his conscious mind ever could.
Here is the consequence that matters. Because expertise moves below awareness, the person who holds it often cannot describe it. They can perform it, but they cannot report it. This is why asking an expert what they do so often produces the same useless answer the shooters gave me: I focus. I practise. I stay calm. The gap between what experts do and what experts say they do is not concealment. It is the natural shape of unconscious competence. The knowledge is real and it is running the performance, but it is stored in a form the verbal, reporting part of the mind cannot easily read.
NLP treats this as a solvable problem rather than a dead end. If the expertise is stored in internal experience, then internal experience becomes the place to look for it. By watching eye movements, listening to the language people use when they describe a skill, noticing the postures and images that accompany peak moments, a modeller can reconstruct the pattern that the expert cannot voice. The marksman could not tell me how he shot. His body, his imagery, and his rehearsal could. When I mapped those internal events into a teachable sequence, eighteen-year-old conscripts who had never finished first ran the protocol and took the regional title for the first time in the unit's history the following year.
Let me be straight about the strength of that claim, because intellectual honesty is part of treating evidence properly. That outcome is a single, powerful case drawn from real practice, not a controlled trial with a comparison group. I watched the change happen across a real team with real stakes, and the pattern has held across decades of similar work, but I will not dress it up as laboratory proof it is not. Modeling disciplines earn credibility through repeated application in real conditions, and that is a real kind of evidence. It is trained on observation, not on double-blind experiments, and it deserves to be weighed accurately rather than oversold in either direction.
Why Willpower Is Not the Skill, and Why Reading Your Own Experience Is
Here is the uncomfortable truth the sleeping shooter exposed for me. The people who get the most from this work are not the ones who try hardest. They are the ones who trust their own experience enough to look at it. The shooter who rehearsed in his sleep was not disciplining himself to think about shooting. He had installed the skill so deeply that his unconscious ran it for him, and he trusted the process enough to let it. The man who screamed to spike adrenaline was not ignoring his nervous system. He was reading it, learning what raised it and what wounded it, and using that internal knowledge to prepare his body for the real conditions of competition.
Most leaders do the opposite. They treat the internal world as a distraction from the real work. The knot in the stomach before a tough conversation is something to push through rather than read. The exhaustion is a weakness to override with caffeine and willpower. The recurring image of a failing outcome is a pessimistic thought to banish rather than a signal about what needs preparation. Each of these reactions throws away data that the person is perfectly positioned to read, and that no outside expert can read for them.
This is why the epistemology choice precedes every technique. Until you decide your internal experience is legitimate data, no amount of anchoring, reframing, or state work will hold for you, because you will keep dismissing the very evidence that tells you whether it is working. You will ask for external proof of a change that only you can feel from the inside. The moment you grant your own experience standing as evidence, the techniques have a substrate to operate on. That is not a philosophical luxury. It is the practical precondition for the whole method.