All lessonsBusiness & Leadership

Culture Is the Behaviour You Tolerate

The best salesperson interrupted a junior analyst twice and the founder said nothing. By Thursday the room had learned which behaviour carried no cost. Culture lives in what is tolerated, not what is posted. Here is Schein’s model, Kerr’s reward mismatch, and the repair conversation that resets a standard.

2026-10-23 2,510 words 13 min read

The Meeting After the Meeting

The sales director was the best performer in the company. He had closed the two largest accounts of the year, and he knew it. In a Tuesday review, he interrupted a junior analyst twice, dismissed her projection with a laugh, and moved the conversation to his own pipeline.

The founder was in the room. He noticed the interruption. He said nothing, partly because the numbers were good and partly because the meeting was running late.

By Thursday, three people had learned something. The analyst learned that her work could be dismissed without consequence. The sales director learned that his behaviour had no cost. The rest of the room learned which of those two facts the company actually believed.

Nothing was written down. No policy changed. The culture moved, and it moved in the direction of the behaviour that was tolerated.

Edgar Schein described culture as a pattern of basic assumptions that a group has invented, discovered or developed in learning to cope with its problems, and that has worked well enough to be considered valid and taught to new members (Schein, 1985, Organizational Culture and Leadership, Jossey-Bass). The assumptions are transmitted through what happens, not through what is announced.

The founder's silence was a lesson, and the lesson was more persuasive than any values statement on the wall.

It is worth being precise about what the founder chose. He did not choose to endorse the interruption. He chose not to interrupt it, and the room could not see the distinction. Silence is read as permission, which is why the smallest inaction carries the largest cultural signal.

Three Levels, One Real One

Schein's model separates culture into artefacts, espoused values and basic assumptions.

Artefacts are the visible things: the office, the rituals, the org chart, the language, the posters. Espoused values are the stated beliefs: the company values transparency, excellence, respect. Basic assumptions are the unwritten beliefs that actually drive behaviour: what happens when you disagree with the founder, whether bad news is safe, who is allowed to be late.

The gap between espoused values and basic assumptions is where most culture work fails. A company can state that it values candour while its basic assumption is that the founder does not want to hear bad news. The statement is not a lie. It is an aspiration, and the assumption is the operating system.

The artefacts reveal the assumptions to anyone who reads them carefully. Who speaks first in meetings. Whose calendar is protected. Which behaviour gets celebrated at the all-hands. Which behaviour gets a promotion. The artefacts are the evidence, and the evidence is usually more honest than the values page.

For a founder, the practical question is not what the company says it believes. It is what a new hire would learn in their first month by watching, without anyone explaining.

Read the artefacts before you read the values. The artefacts have less reason to flatter.

The Tolerance Test

Behaviour that is tolerated becomes the standard, and the mechanism is normative rather than formal.

Robert Cialdini and his colleagues distinguished descriptive norms, what people actually do, from injunctive norms, what people approve of (Cialdini, Reno & Kallgren, 1990, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology). In ambiguous situations, people follow the descriptive norm because it tells them what is normal, even when the injunctive norm says something different.

A company that preaches respect and tolerates public humiliation has a strong descriptive norm and a weak injunctive one. The descriptive norm wins, because it is observable and the injunctive norm is only stated.

The tolerance test is simple. List the behaviours that have happened more than once without a consequence. That list is the culture, regardless of what the values document says.

The list usually includes small things that feel too minor to address. A meeting that starts late. A message that goes unanswered for a week. A joke that lands badly. Each one is a data point about what the group will accept, and the accumulation is the culture.

There is a version of this that affects performance directly. A team that tolerates missed commitments learns that commitments are aspirational. A team that tolerates public criticism learns that the safest strategy is to avoid visibility. The behavioural norm becomes the operating constraint.

There is a practical way to find the list without relying on memory. Ask five people from different levels one question: what is one thing here that everyone complains about and nobody changes? The overlap across the five answers is the tolerated behaviour. The question works because it asks about observation rather than opinion, and the repetition across levels removes the individual grievance.

Once the list exists, sort it by cost. Some tolerated behaviours are preferences that cause mild friction. Others are setting the standard for how work gets done. The sort matters because a founder who treats every item as equally serious will spend the month on the small ones and run out of attention before reaching the expensive one.

The Reward Mismatch

Steven Kerr described the problem in a paper whose title has survived for five decades: on the folly of rewarding A, while hoping for B (Kerr, 1975, Academy of Management Journal).

Organisations often reward the behaviour they say they do not want, because the reward system is built on measurable outputs while the desired behaviour is harder to measure. A sales director who hits the number is rewarded, even when the method damages the team. A manager who avoids conflict is promoted, even when the avoidance leaves problems unresolved.

The mismatch is not usually a failure of intent. It is a failure of measurement. The output is visible and the behaviour is not, so the output gets rewarded and the behaviour gets discussed.

The cost appears later. The high performer's behaviour becomes the template for anyone who wants to succeed, and the template selects for the behaviour rather than against it. Within a year, the company has more people who behave that way, because that is what the reward system purchased.

Jeffrey Pfeffer and Robert Sutton described the related gap between knowing and doing in organisations, arguing that companies often know what to do and fail to act because the systems and incentives point elsewhere (Pfeffer & Sutton, 2000, The Knowing-Doing Gap, Harvard Business School Press). Culture is one of those systems, and it is usually the one with the strongest grip.

The Exception That Becomes the Rule

The most expensive tolerance is the exception granted to a high performer.

The logic is tempting. The person produces disproportionate value, the behaviour is unpleasant but contained, and the cost of replacing them feels higher than the cost of accommodating them. The founder makes a private calculation and decides to absorb the friction.

The calculation misses three costs.

The first is the precedent. The exception is observed, and the team learns that the rules apply differently to people who produce. The lesson is not contained to the high performer, because the team generalises it.

The second is the exit. The people who leave because of the behaviour are often the ones with the strongest standards, and their departure is quiet. The company keeps the person who produces and loses the people who would have built the next thing.

The third is the founder's attention. The exception requires ongoing management, because the behaviour keeps producing incidents that need smoothing. The founder spends energy on containment that could have been spent on the business.

The repair is not necessarily dismissal. It is a direct conversation that names the behaviour, states the standard and describes the consequence. The conversation is uncomfortable and it is the only move that preserves both the person and the culture. A founder who avoids it has chosen the culture over the person while pretending to choose the person over the culture.

Protect the standard and the performer together, or the standard will not survive the performer.

How the Room Updates

Culture spreads through observation, and the observation is fast.

Albert Bandura's social learning research showed that people acquire behaviour by watching models and the consequences that follow, and that the learning occurs without direct reinforcement (Bandura, 1986, Social Foundations of Thought and Action, Prentice-Hall). In an organisation, the model is whoever holds status, and the consequence is whatever happened to them.

This explains why culture change fails when it is delivered as a programme. A training session teaches a behaviour and the room returns to a system that rewards the old one. The observation of the system overrides the instruction in the session, and the instruction is forgotten within a month.

It also explains why small corrections have disproportionate effects. A founder who addresses one behaviour in public, immediately and proportionately, changes the observation for everyone in the room. The correction is the curriculum.

Jennifer Chatman and Sandra Cha argued that leaders can leverage culture by making the desired behaviour concrete, modelling it consistently and aligning the reward system with it (Chatman & Cha, 2003, California Management Review). The three moves are sequential. A leader who models the behaviour while rewarding the opposite produces cynicism, which is more corrosive than the original behaviour.

The room updates on the evidence of consequences. A stated value without a consequence is a preference. A value with a consequence is a norm.